ReddyGet a free demo
Menu

How to set up your lead follow-up: what you keep and what you hand off

Updated Oct 28, 2026

Every lead goes through the same few steps. Someone reaches out, you answer, you find out what they want, and you stay in touch until they are ready. Most agents lose leads in the gaps between those steps, not in the steps themselves: a reply that waits until tonight, a note that never gets written, a check-in that slips to next month. This guide sets up each step and splits it in two: the part that needs you, and the part that doesn't.

Step 1: Catch every lead in one place

Leads come in by phone, text, email, portals, and social messages. When they land in five places, the one you check least loses. Decide on one place where every new lead ends up, with the person's name, how to reach them, where they came from, and what they asked for. A lead that isn't written down there doesn't exist yet.

You do

  • Deciding which sources count as leads, and where they all end up

Hand off

  • Logging each new person with their source and first message
  • Spotting the same person reaching out twice

Step 2: Answer the first message fast

The first reply decides whether the lead keeps talking to you or to the next agent they contacted. It doesn't need to be long. It needs to come soon, answer what they asked, and offer a time to talk. Write a short reply for your most common first messages (a listing question, a showing request, a "what's my home worth") so nothing waits for you to find the words.

You do

  • The first call or meeting

Hand off

  • A first reply, ready for you to review and send
  • A note for every missed call: who called, what they wanted, and when to call back

Step 3: Qualify on the phone, not in writing

Timeline, financing, area, and must-haves are a conversation. People tell you more on the phone than in a form, and the call is where they decide to trust you. What you don't need to do is type it all up afterwards.

You do

  • The qualifying conversation

Hand off

  • Notes from the call on the person's record
  • The next step, and when it's due

Step 4: Set the follow-up rhythm by stage

A buyer touring this weekend and a seller thinking about next spring need different follow-up. Give each stage its own rhythm, for example: daily until the first meeting, weekly while they are actively looking, and monthly while they wait. Every touch should carry something useful, such as a new listing, a price change, or an answer to a question they asked, not "just checking in".

You do

  • Deciding which stage each person is in
  • The calls when someone is ready to move

Hand off

  • Reminders when a touch is due
  • Draft check-ins with something useful in them

Step 5: Review once a week

Once a week, look at who went quiet, who moved stages, and who needs a call. This is the step that catches everyone the rest of the system missed. Keep it short, and end it with a list of calls to make.

You do

  • The calls on the list

Hand off

  • The list itself: who went quiet, who is due, and who hasn't heard from you

Where Reddy fits

Reddy takes over part of the hand-off column, from the chat you already use. It answers calls on your Reddy line and keeps a record of what was said, and it writes replies as drafts in your own mailbox, so you review and send them yourself.

The calls, the meetings, and the decisions stay with you.

Read next

Guides

Hand off the work

Get a free demo, and we'll map these steps to your business.

Put Reddy to workTry for free
See pricingPut Reddy to workTry for free